Daniel Penny indicted by a grand jury for the death of Jordan Neely, a NYC subway rider, in a chokehold incident

15/06/2023 à 21:39:47

- history8 months

| publicCRIME


Daniel Penny, charged with manslaughter for a fatal chokehold incident on the New York City subway, has been indicted by a grand jury, allowing the case to proceed, amidst debates over racial injustice and self-defense claims.

A grand jury has indicted Daniel Penny, a man charged with manslaughter for his involvement in a fatal chokehold incident on a New York City subway, allowing the criminal case to proceed. The incident, which resulted in the death of Jordan Neely, a former Michael Jackson impersonator struggling with homelessness and mental illness, has sparked discussions surrounding racial injustice and self-defense claims. This article delves into the latest developments in the case and the reactions it has elicited from various parties.

Manhattan prosecutors had previously charged Daniel Penny in relation to the May 1st incident that claimed the life of Jordan Neely. The grand jury's proceedings have remained confidential, with no official statements from the Manhattan District Attorney's office. However, New York City Mayor Eric Adams confirmed the indictment, expressing his appreciation for the thorough investigation conducted by District Attorney Alvin Bragg. Mayor Adams reiterated his confidence in the judicial process and highlighted the importance of the trial and the pursuit of justice.

On that fateful day, Jordan Neely, visibly agitated and struggling with homelessness and mental illness, was shouting at passengers and soliciting money. In response to Neely's behavior, Daniel Penny, assisted by two other riders, restrained him by pinning him to the floor of the moving subway car. Penny, a former U.S. Marine, proceeded to apply a chokehold that lasted over three minutes. Penny claimed he was defending himself and the other passengers, alleging that Neely had threatened him with statements like "I'm gonna' kill you" and expressed a readiness to face a life sentence in jail.

A freelance journalist who recorded the incident stated that Neely was acting aggressively and causing fear among passengers but had not physically assaulted anyone. The journalist's account provides additional context to the incident, highlighting the tense atmosphere on the subway car. Importantly, the incident involved a racial dimension, as Neely was Black and Penny is white.

Daniel Penny's legal representatives, Steven Raiser and Thomas Kenniff, acknowledged the grand jury's decision to proceed with the case. They emphasized that the low standard of proof in a grand jury setting does not equate to a finding of wrongdoing. The defense maintained that Penny's actions were justifiable and that his intention was to hold Neely until the police arrived, rather than causing his death. Raiser expressed confidence that, when presented with the evidence, a trial jury would find Penny's actions fully justified.

Neely's tragic death stirred protests from many who viewed it as an instance of racial injustice. However, Daniel Penny also found support, including from several Republican presidential candidates. A legal defense fund established for Penny has amassed over $2.8 million in contributions, according to his lawyers.

Daniel Penny, aged 24, had been released on a $100,000 bond following his arraignment on May 12. With the new indictment, he will be required to return to court for another arraignment. Prosecutors in New York needed a grand jury indictment to proceed with the case against Penny. If convicted, he could face significant prison time.

The indictment of Daniel Penny by a grand jury paves the way for the manslaughter case to move forward in the incident involving the fatal chokehold on the New York City subway. The case has garnered attention due to its racial undertones and conflicting accounts of self-defense. As legal proceedings progress, the public will await the trial's outcome, hoping for a just resolution in this tragic and highly debated case.


These articles are produced using artificial intelligence, then refined by our team of administrators, based on the most relevant news information. We encourage you to contact us at if you notice any errors.